Asylum Scandals: Honest and Powerful Facts Revealed

by | May 23, 2022 | asylum scandals | 0 comments

Photo by Tama66

Many asylum scandals have occurred worldwide, and we are now discovering their hidden truths.

Asylum Scandals by Patricia Lubeck is a book that talks about certain asylum wrongdoings in Minnesota’s state hospitals. In her book, she mentions the abuse, torture, corruption, and murder within the walls of those hospitals.

With that said, let’s look at the honest and powerful facts these scandals revealed. Indeed, there are more than a handful of scandals out there, but we will only be talking about two of them here. But rest assured that they’ll show you the truths you and everyone else need to know.

Asylum Scandals Behind Minnesota’s State Hospitals

The book Asylum Scandals by Patricia Lubeck reveals the terrible situation for patients confined in the insane asylums. Asylums eventually opened the door for medical practitioners to research people with mental illness, despite their original purpose of providing a place to keep craziness out of society. The asylums were opulent structures set among sizable, beautifully planted grounds.

These facilities gradually became neglected and squalor due to overcrowding, poorly trained employees, and dishonest management. Having an enormous cost of upkeep for the colossal structures was beyond the capacity of state support. With the number of admitted patients increased over time, making it challenging to meet the need for better care.

Eventually, several state hospitals were shut down by the 1980s. In this book, the two oldest state hospitals in Minnesota—St. Peter, founded in 1866, and Rochester, founded in 1879—are chronicled. Laws at the time, permitted families to commit a spouse, family member or acquaintance to the state hospital with little to no proof.

What Other Asylum Abuse Happened in Minnesota’s State Hospitals?

People were frequently committed against their will and never released. Asylum Scandals provides a picture of life in the state hospitals between 1867 and 1915. Authentic experiences of patients who saw abuse, neglect, torture, and murder are included.

Torturous medical procedures like lobotomies, electric shock therapy, and hydrotherapy sprays existed. Along with the many asylum scandals, these are only a small example. Many more truths about the terrible things inside the stone construction of the state hospitals have yet to be exposed.

Another Asylum Mistreatment Worth Talking About

When the York Lunatic Asylum first opened its doors in 1777, little was known about mental disease. Families were forced to make the best decisions they could for the mentally ill within their homes because there was no organized institutional care accessible.

It was common practice to chain insane people to the walls, leave them nude (because it was believed that mentally ill people could not sense cold), and isolate them. People who were insanely changed into beasts.

York Lunatic Asylum quickly veered away from its original, lofty goals of offering relief to those miserable patients who are a source of compassion and terror to everyone around them. Hannah Mills, a Quaker, passed away at the York Asylum in 1790.

Throughout her six-week stay, no friends were permitted to visit her, support her faith, or observe the conditions of her detention. William Tuke encouraged the creation of the Retreat in York. As a result, an organization based on the Quaker principle that all individuals should be treated with kindness and equality.

People Continued to Worry About Asylum Mistreatment in York

The York Asylum began to raise more and more questions. A Justice of the Peace for the West Riding named Godfrey Higgins became involved in the case after the asylum employees mistreated William Vickers. Vickers had left the hospital battered, disgusting, filthy, and weak to the point he could not stand.

Reverend Schorey, who was pushed down the flight of stairs by his keeper, and Martha Kidd, whose hip had dislocated while she was a patient, were two more patients who had received subpar care.

Nearly 40 local guys (which includes relatives of the Tuke family and some of their acquaintances) took advantage of an outdated rule during a meeting scheduled to discuss Higgins’ allegations. To become the asylum’s governors and make changes, they also paid £20.

The scandals that happened in asylums are genuinely unforgivable things. Asylum Scandals by Patricia Lubeck tells us the story we need to know. Patient accounts, what happened within silenced walls, and the atrocious secrets many higher-ups tried to bury.

By uncovering these asylum scandals, we are giving closure to many families and patients (both living and those who passed away) that they deserve.

Get a copy of Patricia Lubeck’s book titled Asylum Scandals by clicking here!

Writing to Reveal the Truth: Accuracy Without Exaggeration

A woman secretly writing about the commotion in the medical institution | Image FX At its heart, writing to reveal the truth is about honoring facts with empathy, crafting stories that respect reality without exaggeration, and trusting readers to embrace honest...

Inside the Asylum: A Dark History of Mental Health Treatment

Image from Freepik To understand the complicated journey of mental health treatment, one must begin inside the asylum. These places were built to offer refuge to individuals struggling with mental illness. At first glance, they seemed to provide a solution. But inside...

Intentional Legal and Ethical Lapses of Asylum Scandals

Photo from freepik Asylums were meant to help people, but they quickly became the antithesis of their inception. Reading through Patricia Lubeck's Asylum Scandals: Abuse, Torture, Corruption, and Murder in Minnesota's State Hospitals, you see how these institutions...

Under the Spotlight: How Writing Uncovers Asylum Scandals

Photo by user34710080 Asylum Scandals by Patrica Lubeck puts mental institutions in Minnesota under the spotlight, especially those that have had a history of asylum scandals. Beyond the nature and theme of the book, it is also a reminder of the necessity and...

Cures or Control? The Ethics of Psychiatric Treatment

Photo by Abdiel Ibarra on Unsplash Understanding ethics in the concept of psychiatric treatment touches on human rights, consent, and the thin line between help and coercion. The distinction between harm and benefit in the context of mental health care has frequently...

Controversies in Psychiatric History: The Dark Chapters

Photo by Jon Butterworth on Unsplash Learning How Psychiatry Began and Controversies in Psychiatric History Over the decades, psychiatry—the area of medicine that focuses on mental health—has advanced significantly.  Compassion, evidence-based treatment, and...

The Evolution of Painful Treatments: When Medicine Meets Misery

Photo by dolgo ph on Unsplash The evolution of painful treatments is a tragic yet fascinating tale that reflects humanity's ongoing struggle to understand and control the human body. Throughout history, medicine has been a means of healing and a source of immense...

Unethical Treatments in Psychology: Line Between Treatment and Torture

Understanding the human mind has long been at the center of universal intrigue, and in an attempt to do so, psychology has, more than once, blurred ethical lines. To effectively unravel humanity’s intricacies, psychologists had to start somewhere. Unfortunately, for...

The Overlooked Mental Health Crisis: Breaking the Chains

Photo by Andrew Neel on Unsplash Tied up with the overlooked mental health crisis is the growing concern of tossing aside mental health and dismissing its impact on many individuals. It's about time we continue to address and discuss this problem to raise awareness...

Horrors Of An Asylum: The History and Evolution of Asylums

Photo by Jon Butterworth on Unsplash Before the evolution of asylums into the mental health hospitals and clinics we have today, being institutionalised for being mentally ill or unable to function in society meant being confined to an asylum. For centuries, people...

0 Comments

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Films that are set in abandoned asylums - Patricia Lubeck - […] things that happened at St. Peter State Hospital and Rochester State Hospital. The book presents real evidence from patients, families, workers,…
  2. 7 Most Ghastly Insane Asylum Treatments in History - Patricia Lubeck - […] Those were seven of the ghastliest insane asylum treatments in history. If you wish to know more honest and powerful…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share This