A Grim Throwback to Asylums During the Great Depression

^{Photo by Ryan Lum on Unsplash}

Let’s take a step back and reflect on what went on in those asylums during the Great Depression and how it influenced the way society approaches mental health.

Walking through the crumbling halls of an old asylum, the air is thick with the echoes of despair. This haunting image serves as a chilling reminder of the treatment of the mentally ill during one of America’s darkest periods: the Great Depression. Moreover, Asylum Scandals by Patricia Lubeck is a great book that covers many of those grim topics associated with America’s most chilling facilities.

Although several of the asylums gained notoriety for their cruel conditions, the purpose of them was to offer care and sanctuary. Examining this dark period of history exposes the prejudices that society as a whole still holds about mental health, in addition to the difficulties that individuals encounter.

Overview of the Great Depression

Millions of people lost their jobs and homes due to the devastating economic downturn known as The Great Depression. It started in 1929 and continued through the 1930s. Consequently, those channels of assistance broke down, and society’s resources decreased as families faced unemployment and hardship. The desperate demands of the general public frequently took precedence over the predicament of the mentally ill due to the chaotic state of the economy. The stigma around mental illness grew as a result of the widespread belief that it is a human failing rather than a medical ailment.

Societal Attitudes Toward Mental Health

Mental health was not well-regarded and heavily considered during this era. Those with mental health concerns were frequently viewed as a burden on society. Terms like “madness” and “insanity” were often used interchangeably. Instead of a place where patients received help, they became neglectful. In turn, they treated patients more like objects to be contained than treated. This ignorance created the conditions for the horrifying events that would take place inside asylum walls.

How Asylums Played a Part in the Great Depression

^{Photo by Greg Panagiotoglou on Unsplash}

Initially, the purpose of asylums was to provide treatment and rehabilitation for people with mental diseases. However, when the Great Depression hit, these establishments became overcrowded mental health warehouses. Due to a lack of resources and an increase in population, many asylums started to focus more on confinement than on treatment.

The conditions within these asylums were no less than horrifying, to say the least. Patients were frequently placed in cramped rooms with little to no privacy. Unhygienic conditions resulted from the frequent disregard for basic necessities. Survivors’ accounts describe physical restrictions, isolation, and painful rather than helpful treatments, including electroshock therapy and lobotomies. These incidents added to a trauma loop that affected both individuals and families, leaving long-lasting wounds.

Voices of Survivors and Their Families’ Side of the Story

^{Photo by Simon Hurry on Unsplash}

To fully comprehend the effects of this difficult time, hearing from people who experienced it is essential. Survivors describe horrifying experiences of being beaten, imprisoned, and deprived of their freedom. The facility was referred to as “a living nightmare” by a former inmate, who saw hopelessness smother optimism. These tales are potent reminders of the human cost associated with disregarding mental health.

And the emotional toll on families was just as terrible. The shame of having a loved one institutionalized was experienced by many relatives. Families were frequently split apart as members struggled with feelings of powerlessness and guilt. Placing a family member in an asylum was a difficult decision. Because the family understood that once the person was entered, there was little chance they would be allowed to return home. Long after the doors had closed, the pain of their loved ones continued to haunt them.

Post-Great Depression Changes

Attitudes on mental health care changed in the middle of the 20th century as the atrocities of asylum life became more well known. A movement for more humane care as an alternative to institutionalization started to take shape. Deinstitutionalization began at this point, with many patients being discharged from asylums. Moreover, they were reintegrated into society with support systems in place.

Lessons Learned Towards a Shift in Mental Health Care

^{Photo by Hans Eiskonen on Unsplash}

The dreadful legacy of the Great Depression’s asylums imparts to us important knowledge about mental health services. It emphasizes the value of empathy and comprehension, including the structural adjustments to how society views mental illness. Let’s move toward a future where mental health is viewed as a basic human right, rather than a stigmatized burden even in its sordid past.

When we think back on the Great Depression asylums, we see a troubling period in our history that we should never forget. The accounts of people who endured suffering inside their walls compel our sympathy and consideration. Let’s keep in mind the lessons learned from the past as we negotiate the complexity of mental health today. Furthermore, we must push for a more compassionate approach to treatment. By doing this, we pay tribute to the people who suffered unspeakable suffering and ensure that this kind of history is never repeated.

If you’re curious and want to know more about the horrors that once resided in these asylums, get a copy of Patricia Lubeck’s Asylum Scandals now!