Under the Spotlight: How Writing Uncovers Asylum Scandals

_{Photo by user34710080}

Asylum Scandals by Patrica Lubeck puts mental institutions in Minnesota under the spotlight, especially those that have had a history of asylum scandals.

Beyond the nature and theme of the book, it is also a reminder of the necessity and importance of these kinds of writings, where abuse and horror must be uncovered and revealed to the masses.

In its most investigative form, writing serves as a critical tool for exposing hidden truths, particularly within the often-opaque world of asylum systems. While Asylum Scandals reveal a whole lot, the exact extent of the terror that ravaged countless individuals may never come to light.

Investigative writing puts these scant moments under the spotlight to reveal the scandals, injustices, and systemic failures that have blighted the lives of thousands.

Uncovering Asylum Scandals

The history of mental healthcare is stained with the dark chapters of asylums—institutions that, for centuries, often served as repositories for society’s inconvenient rather than true places of healing. Behind imposing walls and ornate gates, countless individuals were subjected to horrific abuse, neglect, and malpractice, their cries for help muffled by institutional secrecy.

It was, and continues to be, writing from intrepid journalism to poignant memoirs that have consistently torn down these walls of silence, bringing the truth to light and forcing crucial conversations about human dignity and ethical care.

_{Photo by rawpixel.com}

The First Net Cast: Nellie Bly

One of the most famous and impactful examples of writing exposing asylum horrors came in the late 19th century with Nellie Bly’s groundbreaking investigative journalism. In 1887, Bly, a reporter for Joseph Pulitzer’s New York World, feigned insanity to gain admission to the notorious Women’s Lunatic Asylum on Blackwell’s Island. Her ten days inside were a harrowing immersion into a world of unimaginable cruelty. Bly reported on the cold, indifferent staff who verbally and physically abused patients, the unhygienic conditions, the inedible food, and the forced cold baths that left patients shivering and screaming. Her articles, later compiled into the book Ten Days in a Mad-House, became an instant sensation. This was because Bly’s vivid descriptions and raw honesty thoroughly shocked the public, igniting outrage and leading to significant reforms that greatly transformed mental healthcare in New York City for the better.

The Writer Under the Spotlight

Perhaps the most potent form of writing in this arena has been the personal account. While distant and object reporting gives us a nonbiased perspective, personal narratives of the asylum are raw and deeply affecting.

While their anecdotal nature leads to some dismissing them, their cumulative power is undeniable. They offer an intimate glimpse into the dehumanizing realities of institutionalized life. These stories reveal the deep psychological scars left by abuse, the loss of autonomy, and the struggle for recovery in the aftermath.

Personal accounts serve as a constant reminder that behind every scandal is a human being whose life was irrevocably altered.

Even in contemporary times, asylums in their traditional form have largely been replaced by community-based care, but issues of abuse and malpractice persist in different guises within modern mental health facilities. Undercover investigations by journalists continue to expose negligence, mistreatment, and systemic failures, often prompting swift action and reform. These modern exposés, whether in print or digital format, draw directly from the legacy of writers like Bly, demonstrating that the pen remains a mighty weapon against hidden injustices.

_{Photo from freepik}

The Point of Writing

Writing remains one of society’s best tools to serve as a crucial mirror. In reflecting on society’s treatment of its most vulnerable, we are able to make better sense of what steps are necessary to rectify abuse and maltreatment.

From the historical reports that sparked the first reforms to the personal narratives that bring empathy to the forefront and the investigative journalism that holds power accountable, writing has been an indispensable tool in uncovering asylum scandals. It has not only brought the dark truths to light but has also fueled the ongoing fight for ethical, compassionate, and truly therapeutic mental healthcare, ensuring that the lessons of the past are never fully forgotten.

Patricia Lubeck’s Asylum Scandals: Abuse, Torture, Corruption and Murder in Minnesota’s State Hospitals is a great work of research and journalistic integrity. It is available here on this website.